VATICAN CITY (AP) — Jewish and Muslim leaders on Monday cautiously
praised recent remarks by Pope Benedict XVI, who said that dialogue
among faiths should be pursued even though it is impossible on strictly
The comments in an open letter published Sunday
in Italy’s leading daily, Corriere della Sera, marked the latest
statement by Benedict on the subject.
The pontiff has often
discussed the theme of dialogue among religions and has worked for the
improvement of interfaith relations.
But he also angered many Muslims in a 2006 speech about Islam and violence, although relations have improved since then.
his letter, the pope was commenting on an upcoming book by a
conservative politician and scholar, Marcello Pera, who has long spoken
in defense of Europe’s Christian roots.
The pope said the book
“explains clearly that an interreligious dialogue in the strict sense
of the word is not possible.” The pope elaborated that “real dialogue”
on religious choices is not possible “without putting one’s faith in
But he said that “it’s necessary to face, in a public dialogue, the cultural consequences of fundamental religious choices.”
“Here, dialogue, as well as mutual correction and enrichment, are both possible and necessary,” Benedict wrote.
becoming pope in 2005, Benedict has made improving interfaith relations
a theme of his pontificate. He has visited synagogues during trips to
Germany and the United States, and a mosque during a visit to Turkey.
Earlier this month, the Vatican hosted a Catholic-Muslim conference intended to help the two faiths find common ground.
Vatican spokesman, the Rev. Federico Lombardi, said Benedict’s words do
“not put in doubt the pope’s interreligious commitment.”
dialogue does not mean questioning one’s own faith,” Lombardi said. “It
deals with the many other aspects that come from one’s personal belief,
cultural, historical … as well as their consequences.”
chief rabbi, Riccardo Di Segni, welcomed the pope’s remarks “for their
clarity.” He said the comments were “opportune and interesting” in that
they set the limits of religious dialogue.
“Faiths cannot hold
dialogue beyond a certain point because there are insurmountable
limits,” Di Segni told The Associated Press on Monday. “This is a limit
to all religious dialogue: It’s not like a political negotiation where
I give you this and that and we make peace. It’s not like we give up
Di Segni, however, urged clarification on certain
elements in the pope’s remarks, such as where to draw the line between
religious dialogue as opposed to cultural dialogue.
“He has set the limits, which were necessary. We must then see where it goes from there,” the Jewish leader said.
spokesman for an Italian Muslim Group, UCOII, also called for further
clarification. He told Corriere della Sera that “dialogue among
believers exists: We don’t hold a dialogue on our faiths … but we do
on how we can coexist, each in our diversity.”
Associated Press Writer Daniela Petroff contributed to this report.