CHURCH, Va. (ABP) — The Baptist World Alliance has issued its formal
response to a 2007 letter, written to Christians by 138 Muslim leaders,
describing love for God and love for neighbor as common ground between
the two faiths.
BWA leaders agreed that the double love for God and neighbor “lies at the heart of the
message of Jesus Christ as recorded in the Gospels” but clarified that
Baptists do not understand those commands as “the sum total of our two
The letter cited one example, the Trinity, as
“troubling” for Muslims but “absolutely essential for us in confessing
the oneness of God.”
“We are well aware that Muslims believe
the Christian idea of the Trinity contradicts the affirmation that God
has no other being in association with him,” the Baptist leaders said,
but Christians do not understand “the distinct reality” of God in three
persons to mean that any other being is beside God.
the church is attempting to express the truth that there are
mysterious, unknowable depths to the personal nature of God,” the
letter said. “It is also aiming to be faithful to the truth of God
which has been disclosed in the event of Jesus Christ in history.”
Not an attempt to convince
Baptist leaders said the letter is not the place for “a fuller
exposition of the Christian doctrine of the Trinity” or an attempt to
try to convince Muslims of its truth.
“We write in order to
make clear that we ourselves cannot think of God as love except in
terms of an eternal communion or fellowship whose unity is dynamic and
relational,” the letter said. “While we rejoice to confess with you
that there is one God, it is not possible for us to speak of the one
God without also speaking of Trinity.”
In November 2007 a number of Christian leaders published a statement in the New York Times responding to A Common Word Between Us and You by Muslim scholars and clerics.
by evangelicals including Leith Anderson and Richard Cizik of the
National Association of Evangelicals, Timothy George of Samford
University’s Beeson Divinity School, David Gushee of Mercer University,
Bill Hybels of Willow Creek Church, Richard Mouw of Fuller Theological
Seminary and Rick Warren of Saddleback Church, the Loving God and Neighbor Together response expressed strong agreement with the Muslim letter.
After conservative evangelicals including John Piper, Al Mohler and Focus on the Family’s CitizenLink newsletter criticized the Christian letter for not explicitly affirming the deity of Christ, some of the original signers had their names removed.
During a discussion of a Baptist response to the Islamic letter last summer, according to a report on the website EthicsDaily.com, some Baptists expressed concern about
theological language in the original letter from Islamic leaders.
Meanwhile, some Baptists from areas of the world where Christians and
Muslims clash questioned the need for dialogue.
meeting, BWA leaders drafted a formal response signed by BWA president
David Coffey, General Secretary Neville Callam, Paul Fiddes of the
Commission on Doctrine and Inter-Church Cooperation and Regina Claas of
the Commission on Freedom and Justice.
Thanks for “generous initiative”
BWA letter thanked the Muslim leaders for their “generous initiative”
and “irenic and constructive spirit” in the 2007 letter. The leaders
proposed that future discussions take place not in a central commission
of the BWA but rather in regional unions and conventions engaged in
joint conversations and projects for aid and development.
also called for education of both religious teachers and members of
local congregations and mosques to “change attitudes and prejudices”
that undermine values of respect and honor of others despite differing
“Just one way this may happen is for
religious teachers in both faiths to be careful about the rhetoric they
use, which may have unintended effects on followers who are less aware
of theological nuances, and which may even lead to violence,” the
leaders said. “To be concrete, we have one suggestion for Baptist
Christians, that they avoid words to describe evangelism (or telling
the gospel story) which appear threatening to others, such as
‘evangelistic crusades.’ Nor is it necessary to be critical of another
faith in order to commend what we believe to be true in ours; the story
of Jesus has power to persuade in its own right.”
“It is easy
to slip into a violent rhetoric which arouses unpleasant memories of
conflicts in the past,” the letter said. “We do not venture to suggest
examples of unhelpful rhetoric to you, our Muslim friends, but hope
that you might be able to identify some for yourselves. Let our
rhetoric be that of love, as you have already shown.”
–Bob Allen is senior writer for Associated Baptist Press.